Florida’s Seminole Tribe after once more finds by itself in a predicament the place it is legal to launch the Really hard Rock Bet athletics betting system, but at minimum a person lawyer common with the case claims it is unlikely the tribe will do so.
The U.S. Supreme Courtroom late Wednesday afternoon denied West Flagler and Associates’ (WFA) ask for to continue to be a decreased-court docket ruling, which implies that in the eyes of federal regulation, the Seminoles are totally free to go forward with their system. The denial, even though, doesn’t preclude WFA, which owns two Florida parimutuels, from submitting for a continue to be to preserve the Seminoles offline in the Florida Supreme Court docket, nor does it imply that the circumstances that will make your mind up the upcoming of lawful Florida athletics betting have been made the decision.
“The denial of the stay by the U.S. Supreme Courtroom is very very good news,” a Seminole spokesman instructed Sporting activities Manage by using e-mail. “The Seminole Tribe of Florida is heartened by this determination.”
West Flagler and Associates has publicly claimed that it plans to enchantment its case versus the U.S. Section of the Interior (DOI) by Nov. 20, and a scenario in the Florida Supreme Court is in a holding sample till Dec. 1, the deadline established for Gov. Ron DeSantis and the legislature to react.
“As I have been expressing for some time, it is all above but the shouting on the federal stage,” Nova Southeastern constitutional legislation professor Bob Jarvis informed Sporting activities Handle. “The action now is at the point out stage, in which the Florida Supreme Court will have to determine if it wants the circumstance or needs to send it down to the Leon County circuit court docket. Possibly way, we won’t see athletics betting in Florida for some time nevertheless, but it will occur finally.”
Conclusion an indicator court isn’t fascinated?
The denial could also be a hint as to what is to come on the federal degree, where by a U.S. district court docket in November 2021 sided with West Flagler and a U.S. appellate court docket in June 2023 sided with the DOI. The key to the federal circumstance is no matter if or not DOI Secretary Deb Haaland was in her legal rights to enable the 2021 compact amongst the Seminoles and the point out of Florida to develop into accredited. Haaland did not sign the compact, but somewhat, enable 45 times move prior to it grew to become “deemed approved.”
Florida law firm Darren Heitner of Heitner Lawful informed Sports activities Handle that the denial suggests that “it really should not be lengthy in advance of Florida citizens are in a position to quickly position bets on the Tricky Rock Bet cellular application.”
Sign Up For The Sporting activities Handle Newsletter!
But far more importantly, he states the denial is a notify.
“By not issuing a keep, SCOTUS has signaled that it is not likely to get the situation and/or reverse the underlying conclusion,” he said.
JUST IN: The Supreme Court just denied a continue to be in the Florida sporting activities betting circumstance.
Wagering on the @HardRockBet application will be coming extremely shortly. pic.twitter.com/lxUFMKW4GD
— Andy Slater (@AndySlater) Oct 25, 2023
Supremes supply fodder for condition-stage situation
Wednesday’s denial raises significant inquiries bordering the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote in a statement that he agrees with the denial “in gentle of the D.C. Circuit’s pronouncement that the compact amongst Florida and the Seminole Tribe authorizes the Tribe to perform only on-reservation gaming functions, and not off-reservation gaming functions.”
But in thinking about all views of the compact, Kavanaugh also wrote, “If the compact approved the Tribe to perform off-reservation gaming operations, both specifically or by deeming off-reservation gaming operations to by some means be on-reservation, then the compact would probably violate the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, as the District Court docket discussed.”
The compact does, in simple fact, make it possible for for any bet positioned any where in the state of Florida to be considered to have been placed in Indian Place if the bet flows by way of a server on tribal land. Florida’s legislature authorised the compact in a Could 2021 unique session. But the federal courts do not govern what is in the compact, nor do they have a say in point out law.
Kavanaugh also calls into question equal protection concerns, citing the Florida law that gives the Seminoles a monopoly, and also writes, “But the state law’s constitutionality is not squarely offered in this software, and the Florida Supreme Court docket is in any event presently contemplating point out-legislation difficulties connected to the Tribe’s prospective off-reservation gaming operations.”
It would appear possible that WFA will file for a keep to keep the Seminoles from launching with the Florida Supreme Court docket quicker fairly than afterwards. When they submitted a movement in Florida Supreme Court past week, WFA legal professionals wrote that when they did not originally request “emergency relief” to retain the Seminoles offline, they would if the scenario were being to drag on.
